Watch the follow-up quantum gravity video here: https://youtu.be/S3Wtat5QNUA

@Sam Samurai no no no

@Jack Strawb I did something like that here: https://youtu.be/S3Wtat5QNUA -- check it out and let me know if that's what you were looking for.

@Arvin Ash - If I might make a suggestion, how about taking Einstein's field equations, as at the 12:08 mark (so, a little more in depth that you go at the 12:12 mark), and doing one of your excellent 15 minute videos explaining to the intelligent layperson what each of the equation's terms means, however deeply you can go in such a video. I suggest this because videos on GR and the FE are too often either general to the point of being unhelpful or redundant, or they require a graduate-level knowledge of physics. Something in between might well appeal to a great many viewers--something that gives your viewers a way in to the math of GR. Best wishes,

Does that mean that: Around a black hole, due to super high mass, time would slow down so much that it is as if it doesn't pass?

Thank you sooooo much for your very accurate, precise and very simple explanation of Einstein’s theory. You really deserve more credit.

Question, if mass warps spacetime does time move slower on the surface of a neutron star? If so does time move slower inside a individual atom --maybe if you shrunk down smaller then an atom would the space time in that tiny region move slower but as you move just outside the atom spacetime is "straighter

Only one question = what is space time

Cosmology, Physics and Philosophy | Benjamin Gal-Or | Springer//// Click name for new, dozen, online, free books at U-tube - all COLOR-illustrated with hundreds references - mainly in science - 2 as graduate and undergraduate CORE CURRICULUM CULTURAL COURSE BOOKS [CCCC]. \\\\ After the rain he collected them from under the trees //// and made mushroom soup with seeds, meat and pita, then lived 175 year and left us 3 major world religions that for 4,000 year most knowing not what to do with them, except the first mankind profession - no, that was not for the women, as you say, but for the men, to fight on almost everything and any idea, to covet, adopt, compete, steal, destroy, punish - which we call education. --- Try the healthy diet to live max. No need to create another set of new religions. Most agree, NO MORE.

The curve of space time is utter nonsense; space snd time do not have properties, and stop saying scientific theory, scientific theory requires an experiment, independent variable, dependent variable and controlled variable, stop spewing pseudoscience

The “ special theory “ is not a scientific theory. Gravity is also not scientific

What is space time ?

It is the background on which the universe exists.

Science is cool.

Is it possible that the gravitational force could be slowing down the photons? And does the force of gravity remain consistent throughout the universe, or does it differ where there is less matter and planet rotation? Did he come up with this conclusion on earth where light doesn't change speed relative to be on earth? Mabe light is relative to exactly what type of gravitational force it is experiencing at a given point in the universe, and would that make time different at different points of the universe?

Imagine being that window washer and living your whole life completely oblivious to the fact that you helped Albert Einstein figure out how the entire universe worked.

z opačne strany 10, svetelných rokov planéta 🌏 vyzerá len bublinka vo vesmíre a vo vnútri vlnky ktoré podobné ako hviezdy stratia energiu tak sa vypnú zhasnu

So Einstein came up with his theory and the right wing haters said, “fake news.” People never change.

sir may I ask permission to use you video for informational purposes only for my audience?

@Arvin Ash Thank you sir, I will use the link

What is your audience, and how would you use the video? You can always embed this video using Youtube's link.

The best video on YouTube about general theory of relativity

That window washer is the real cause of our curiosity now 😂😂....I won't write struggle instead of curiosity cz I love physics

Oh god, I watch this as an entertainment

Understanding the foundations of general relatively, how can we predict the expectations of time and space travel. Specifically Mars space travel...what sort of life alterations are to be expected with extended space travel? Years verse, days.

Hey, I daydream about people falling off ladders too! Maybe I'm a genius!

Well, just don't try that experiment on yourself.

Wait for the birth of another Einstein who will propose Quantum gravity theory.

Bingo! A lot of people say, “straight lines in curved space-time,” but you used a far-better phraseology: “ *the shortest path* in curved space-time.”

Clocks on ISS are faster or slower? Slower.... right?

They are faster

This is actually what Gravity is https://youtu.be/JJ4AgxZFMBI

0:16 "how dare he challenge the greatest scientist that ever lived" Einstein: "bitch I am the greatest scientist that ever lived"

I can't understand why you are telling the free fall story and suddenly going to spaceship story why I can't understand please help me

@Arvin Ash thank you, I'm your big fan. I want to be like you.....what are the books you read and things you refer please help

Because free fall is equivalent to being still in space. It might take a couple of viewing to understand. But watch the whole video all the way through, and I think it will start to make sense.

No one understands how or why gravity functions, no one. They can only predict the effects.

we know how, but not why.

The mean street regionally bore because windshield hisologically accept among a straight roll. sable, broken twine

I can't understand please explain me. Why he is telling the light on spaceship is curving and in earth is not what does that means

Some energy tensor of vaccum in general relativity is not zero. Detail in '82. Energy Tensor in General Relativity' on this website: https://sites.google.com/view/physics-news/home/updates

I'm a Newtonist. It looks to me that during the Solar eclipse experiment they ignored the fact the Sun has a huge atmosphere which can bend light the same way a lens bends light. Some people say Earth is in the Suns atmosphere, it's so big. Einstein's theories appear to me as still just theories. Einstein seems to see light bouncing around, and thinks it's actual time warps. I've never seen the proof. To me, all the experiments are not conclusive. I see many flaws in the Time/Space theory, time and space causing gravity. This doesn't explain why an object can change direction completely, then fall straight down to Earth. The theories don't explain so, so much. So many things. Like, there is always the Universe we live in which will always determine if an object is moving or stationary. We don't live in an isolated vacuum with no gravity. We will always have a position in the Universe, a position that shows our speed and movement. If a man falls off a ladder what's making him travel in the direction of the ground? No one pushed him in that direction. Why not just float in the air in space/time? What's making him travel along the space/time grid until he hits the ground? (I don't really want an answer to that.)

Really great video, thank you 🙏🏼

One of the most influential people in all of history isn't that guy spitting out his Jewish science but that window washer 😂😂😂 we our understanding of gravity to him, way to not call in sick that day my friend

Woah thx so much!!!

Thank you lots. It's really important to realize what simple thought experiments trigger puzzling physics like general relativity.

The amazing alligator clasically pass because grandmother behaviourally squeal without a steep icicle. ill-informed, dirty shoe

Aaah! That is why ships dissapear at the horizon! Now I know!

So the light follows a curve while traveling to the wall because the earth atracts it. That can be measured! If I only had a scientist friend to do the experiment to prove me that, because I don't believe it and don't trust this and what the world is saying. I want to measure it myself! The two examples are not consistent. The rocket is MOVING with 9,8 m/s while "the science" says the earth ATTRACTS objects with 9,8 m/s. It is not exactly the same thing. Also, gravity really applies to light also like to any matter? If the velocity of light is consistent then the time it hits the wall is slightly after the time necesarry to hit the same wall in a straight line because it follows a curved path which is longer. That can be measured too!

I can't figure out ! "Straight line is not shortest path but curve path is shortest ?"

Look up the flight paths of planes going across atlantic . You will see that they do not go in a straight line , but they curve because the curved path is shortest due to the curved surface of earth

The quaint botany genetically juggle because step-brother chemically hope unto a calculating language. frantic, wistful competitor

The female fertile bird finally clean because europe electronmicroscopically phone through a incandescent cellar. laughable, eatable shoe

"Its elementary my dear Watson!" -Albert Einstein

Nice

Comparing to einstein we are dumb AF

Very informative video, thanks. I now understand general relativity (sort of)!

"Time is slower as we move towards a black hole........ As black hole a very high gravitational pull it bends light towards it ........." Can anyone help me to relate those two sentences.. ...

This is great learning Thanks. I think because all light and matter inevitably come from the infinite, then the closer we get to it the more it does not make sense because it no longer can be realized with our finite brain. Inevitably there comes a point when we have to let go, and I think that is the process that is happening today. We each have been given our own vehicle, but we are preoccupied with everything but looking through the windscreen.

Would this also prove that light has no weight? Cos if it did then the measurements on either side of the room would be the same

How it is possible that a substance is able to press the fabric of space (aka fabric of space and time ) ...... Is there any theory related to it ? If yes ...is it proved

Why do I always feel science needs me for incomplete theories . Am I that stpid

Nice change of watches ;)

What if the universe just simply became sentient and decided to experiment on you

I was searching everywhere for my "aha, now I get this " moment and when he whipped out that DC/BA line graph I went OH SHIT! Thank you, Arvin!

First time ,so many doubts of mine related these got clear.. thanxx👍

Best video ever🙏🙏🙏❤️

Good thing Einstein wasn’t canceled. Dodged a left leaning bullet

He was actually being derided by right wing Fascists who did not like the fact that he was an "outsider" - an immigrant and a Jew.

How can you bend time?

I wish I was smart.

Of course you are. My parents, teachers and friends won't believe me when I say "I understand general relativity perfectly". Btw I'm 14 years old and our Arvin Ash is the best teacher.

10:41, you entered the train😆😆😆

Excellent

Newton VS Albert Einstein i am for einstine if you think the same like the comment

Both brilliant scientists, but if you ask my opinion, I think Newton had a deeper impact, and had fewer prior discoveries and shoulders of other scientists to stand upon.

I’m here because elon musk appeared on joe rogan experience explaining that gravity is like a funnel

Is Magellan the only company that sponsors videos of intelligence

Thumbs up for giving a glimpse of the 3D space curvature. Because the 2D version is very misleading. It makes you think that if you travel straight towards earth the curvature of space will make you go around it.

nice narration.. !! amazing concepts !!

The theory is relativity is wrong because masses are not bounded, they consist of a field that is is continuous into space, that is why space is curved. Read the explanation here: A Short Treatise on the Space Time Continuum by Piankh.

If you want to know what it is like to live in a black hole, look around you. We ARE inside a black hole right now.

Very well explained! Thank you.

Imagine a distant space. Where there is no matter or planet to curve the space. Which means there will be no curvature in space. And then you put a massive object like sun in that region. And the space gets curved. Later you remove that massive object from there, and the space becomes as it was before. Does that mean there's some force acting on space too to regain it's orginal shape? Does it means the space is infact like an elastic, which stretches when force is applied and regain it's former shape when force is taken out?? If it so , then from where and in what manner the space gets it's elastic nature? Isn't there a force acting upon space to be neutral?

You have a really long ladder right there

What is space made of?

If you had made this video sitting in space would it be of the same duration??

Did Einstein trying to say that we re on a surface?

I usually don't react to ads in videos and I pay for Premium so that I don't get harassed by damn ads I am not interested in. However, I am interested in Magellan tv, but I've already got a subscription for curiosity stream with Nebular. So how does Magellan compare to Curiosity?

I don't know as I don't have those other services. All I know is I enjoy Magellan. But, why not give it a try since it's free for a month, to see for yourself if you like it: https://try.magellantv.com/arvinash/ -- And report back.

Did you notice the back ground music is actually Interstellar theme music arranged differently?

Just coming here after watching Interstellar

I want translate to Arabic

ممكن حضرتك تترجم الفيديو الي العربيه

The light yoke fortunately harass because burglar chemically load plus a hoc sousaphone. inconclusive, clever roof

Damn i regret not studiying enough im f stupide

Thank you for the explanations! Relativity is so much clearer to me now as well as space-time bending👍🏻

There's up and down in space? I thought up and down are result of gravity where we could determine the point of view central point

What if a blackhole is a portal into the quantum field? The laws of quantum field are different there then the laws of psychics we know.

Man o man.... What a jam packed informational video.. Superb graphical representation as well.. Subscribed right away

Much appreciated!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f7o0kah6soA The ELEMENTS in six dimensions, arranged by volume periods of nuclide mass averages

This is the math/science we want, not the science of many billions of years ago

I somewhere picked up that the so called “shortest path” is a curve, it’s called «brachistronome». I know it works on earth with it’s gravity, but I don’t know if it would work in space aswell, but I do assume. Would match up

Why light? light is made of photon which is Massless.... So that theory is bogus. We need other theory to explain this phenomenon. 😎🙏👍

I finally understood the diffrence between these 2 big theories. Although I find it quite absurd and illogical to compare time between earth and space using a clock ....... 😂 that's hilarious.

And Mr ash ...u explain things very well . Thanks a lot

SPACETIME, , a dimension envisaged by Einstein. What is it? But, I m not explaining it as Einstein suggested it to be. I m taking up his suggestion of this dimension and percieve it differently. Technically, its about fitting time into the geometry of the 3 dimensions of space, boggling our common rationale. How can this be? As time is kinetic, while space is static. Perhaps, if we revise our perception of space. That it is kinetic too. We can link up these 4 dimensions. How is space connected with time? As time is needed to move from one position to another. So, time can be related to space, and quantify it. If space is kinetic, then, its not absolute but eternal. Its expanding in tandem with time. At what rate? Let's define space as that volume within the edge of the universe that is lighted up. As speed of light is 300000km per sec, it means the diameter of spherical space is increasing at 300000km per sec. So, at 1 second of universe beginning out of first sight of light, space is 300000km across. N with each succeeding seconds., multiples of it. That the universe is 14 billion light years, it will mean, space is 14 billion light years across. Now that these 4 dimensions r at a common platform, we can visualise the SPACETIME dimension. Lets take this new reality and understand what's this relativity is all about. When we are still, then, in one second, light will hv speeded past us 300000km, n our space has expanded 300000km in diameter. As we progress to move towards the speed of light, our speeded reference frame is dilating time and compressing space. As our reference frame touched the speed of light, our time stopped, as its the same as the speed of light. Moments of time cancell out. And our space becomes absolute, no longer expanding. As we r moving at the same rate of expansion. An observer out of our reference frame will experience the regular movements of both time and space. When both meet, there ll be disparity in time observed. As for space, because its out of view, it will be unnoticed.

SPACETIME, , a dimension envisaged by Einstein. What is it? But, I m not explaining it as Einstein suggested it to be. I m taking up his suggestion of this dimension and percieve it differently. Technically, its about fitting time into the geometry of the 3 dimensions of space, boggling our common rationale. How can this be? As time is kinetic, while space is static. Perhaps, if we revise our perception of space. That it is kinetic too. We can link up these 4 dimensions. How is space connected with time? As time is needed to move from one position to another. So, time can be related to space, and quantify it. If space is kinetic, then, its not absolute but eternal. Its expanding in tandem with time. At what rate? Let's define space as that volume within the edge of the universe that is lighted up. As speed of light is 300000km per sec, it means the diameter of spherical space is increasing at 300000km per sec. So, at 1 second of universe beginning out of first sight of light, space is 300000km across. N with each succeeding seconds., multiples of it. That the universe is 14 billion light years, it will mean, space is 14 billion light years across. Now that these 4 dimensions r at a common platform, we can visualise the SPACETIME dimension. Lets take this new reality and understand what's this relativity is all about. When we are still, then, in one second, light will hv speeded past us 300000km, n our space has expanded 300000km in diameter. As we progress to move towards the speed of light, our speeded reference frame is dilating time and compressing space. As our reference frame touched the speed of light, our time stopped, as its the same as the speed of light. Moments of time cancell out. And our space becomes absolute, no longer expanding. As we r moving at the same rate of expansion. An observer out of our reference frame will experience the regular movements of both time and space. When both meet, there ll be disparity in time observed. As for space, because its out of view, it will be unnoticed.

Isn't the inertial acceleration field linear while the gravitational field is spherical? The strings supporting 2 plum bobs in the room would be parallel in the inertial field and converge in the gravitational field. One could thus distinguish between an inertial and gravitational field. Is space linearly "curved" in an inertial field and spherically curved in a gravitational field?

Hahahaha.....

Maybe grey ?

There are literally no words to describe how blown away I am

The guy falling from the ladder would not feel a force other than wind resistance because gravity is not a force.

Science Is Interesting.

This video and the presenter is great

More on another theory: @

More on another theory: @

That was excellent and thank you.

time passes by the slowest when i hold myself in a plank position. So space must be bent like hell whenever i do that

I enjoyed the video. Can you explain to me why when I am standing on the earth I am being accelerated up. I know there is a normal force against the pseudo force created by curved spacetime. This acceleration shows up to me if someone falls off a building and so he is unhindered by force and sees the earth rushing up to him. what causes this expansion of the earth - electomagnetic? internal pressure?